Network Computing is part of the Informa Tech Division of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them. Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.

Cut IP Some Regulatory Slack

So it also goes with public telephone service, a century-old cash cow that's on its last legs thanks to the economics of IP communications. Phone companies, state public-service commissions and other industry power brokers desperately want to preserve some semblance of the current system, under which revenue and taxes flow in as reliably as the tides. At risk on open-range IP networks, the defenders of tax-and-regulate telecommunications maintain, are social mandates such as public safety (911 calling), law enforcement (wiretaps), affordable rural telephony (universal service) and access for the disabled. If not the government, who will ensure that IP networks will accommodate those critical needs?

On the other side of the debate are IP-industry pioneers and their constituencies, who call for a market-driven approach that keeps surcharges and regulation to a minimum. The social mandates can be preserved, the pioneers argue, without cramming VoIP into the stifling regulatory taxonomy the Federal Communications Commission applies to basic telephony.

Fortunately for the forces of progress, the current FCC administration, led by chairman Michael Powell, is siding with the pioneers. As a start, the agency ruled this month that Free World Dialup--a members-only service that enables free Internet calls among computers that run special FWD software--isn't subject to conventional telephony regulations. Still to be decided, however, is how to handle commercial IP voice services routed over circuit-switched networks; FWD's service runs over broadband connections to the Internet.

As for how emergency calling, universal access and other social services would be provided in an IP world, the FCC has organized an industry "solutions summit" to develop discrete requirements. It appears the FCC will indeed regulate VoIP--but with precision.

Already, members of the VON Coalition, an IP communications industry group, have struck an agreement with the National Emergency Number Association to develop the technical and operational means to reach 911 services via VoIP--a sign that the private sector can aspire to public policy goals voluntarily. Private interests can be expected to tackle access for the disabled with equal vigor, since it's in their commercial interests to keep the regulators and tax collectors at bay. As for universal service, Moore's Law should take care of that challenge as VoIP technology becomes ever cheaper.

  • 1