Network Computing is part of the Informa Tech Division of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them. Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.

He-Said/He-Said: WiMAX vs. Landline Broadband

Over in our News Analysis section today, we have a story on the IEEE working to boost WiMAX speeds. That led a couple of our editors, Frank Bulk and Sean Ginevan, to debate the prospect of a wireless technology overtaking wired options as a primary wide area data option.
Read their debate now:

Many have questioned just how advantageous WiMax will be in light of forthcoming iterations of current 3G standards (specifically EV-DO Rev C, an evolution of standards used by CDMA carriers, and 3G LTE, an evolution of GSM). Unlike WiMax, evolutions of the current 3G standards will let carriers provide higher speed data services while supporting their current CDMA or GSM customers.

However, IEEE's push to drive 802.16 toward gigabit speed with the 802.16m standard will give the WiMax a competitive advantage. Not only could 802.16m offer new opportunities for wireless services, it also could represent serious competition to wireline Internet access means. Given how notoriously slow the standards process can be (witness the lengthy ratification process of 802.11n), 2009 seems to be a lofty goal. And even if the IEEE does meet that timeline, products based on the standard will no doubt take a good bit of time after that to come to market. -Sean Ginevan, NWC Contributing Editor

I have to disagree [with Sean's statement]. You can't duplicate spectrum, but every cable reproduces a significant portion of spectrum. Wireline services will always stay ahead. There's already talk of 1-Gbps service over cable modems, and 200 Mbps to 300 Mbps over copper (post VDSL2). -Frank Bulk, NWC Contributing Editor

You don't think 1Gbps per cell site would provide competition to wireline services? Sure, cable modems would probably offer more bandwidth per user but, from my own limited understanding, cable modem systems still share bandwidth amongst a subset of users (it's not like you get 1Gbps per user). -Sean Ginevan

1 Gbps per sector would be impressive. I'm not holding my breath to see that, in production, anytime in this decade. Just look at HSDPA theoretical versus actual.

  • 1