Network Computing is part of the Informa Tech Division of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them. Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.

Analysis: Carrier Ethernet: Page 4 of 11

The benefit of MPLS--which is what Qwest's iQ Networking service relies on--is that by sharing long-haul links with other traffic, costs drop compared with a dedicated Sonet circuit. Qwest also offers Ethernet over Sonet, which forms a private circuit with the network connection dedicated just to us--but that service comes at a much higher price. Its recommendation, and we agree, is for Tac-Doh to use VPLS To find out how prices for long-haul Ethernet services compare with SDH/Sonet, see our exclusive cost analysis by TeleGeography's Greg Bryan.

Our network options at that point are to treat the WAN as a switch, directing LAN-to-LAN traffic using VLANs, or to keep our routers at the LAN/WAN edge, but under our administrative control. However, migrating from a routed WAN--which is a typical arrangement--to a switched WAN will require significant changes to our underlying network topology, and significant engineering to flatten the network.

The lesson: While Tac-Doh can still reap Carrier Ethernet's lower cost-per-bit benefits, green-field WAN installations will benefit the most from Carrier Ethernet. Architecture decisions will definitely be easier.

One saving grace is that with Carrier Ethernet, Tac-Doh can migrate from routing to switching slowly, by provisioning one VLAN for routed traffic and adding VLANs for switched traffic. From Qwest's perspective, a VLAN frame is a VLAN frame, regardless of origin or destination.

Take The E Trains