Dave Molta

Network Computing Blogger


Upcoming Events

HDI Service Management 2010 Conference & Expo
October 6-8, Miami

IT service and technical support professionals gather at the annual HDI Service Management Conference & Expo to explore some of the hottest topics affecting IT service management. The half-day conference workshops provide the processes, frameworks, templates, and tools to help you meet the service demands of your business..

More Events »

Subscribe to Newsletter

  • Keep up with all of the latest news and analysis on the fast-moving IT industry with Network Computing newsletters.
Sign Up

Network Neutrality: Reconsidering Flat-Rate Internet Access

Later this week, the FCC is expected to release details of a newly proposed policy addressing network neutrality. These rules, motivated primarily by a desire on the part of the Obama administration to encourage openness and innovation on the Internet, are also mired in intense political debate, some of it ideological but much of it driven by a corrupt system of campaign finance. Corporate donors are staking out their turf and finding compromise won't be easy.

Most tech savvy people understand that the purest form of net neutrality, in which "all packets are treated equally" is a practical impossibility in an era of converged time-sensitive network applications. On the other hand, only naive or disingenuous parties would suggest that a laissez-faire regulatory approach is appropriate for service providers, whose financial motivations and near-monopoly status drives their policies and practices. These are the same folks who believe AT&T blocked Skype on the iPhone because they were concerned about the potential negative impact on current customers. Right.

While much of the historical debate about net neutrality focuses on encouraging non-discriminatory practices amongst wireline Internet service providers, the most fascinating aspects of this debate revolve around wireless providers. On wired networks, performance is mostly an exercise in simple economics. If you want better service, you can throw money at the problem. The same is true of carriers. If we expect them to offer low-cost Internet access services, we have to give them license to manage these services in an appropriate manner.

Longing for the early days

The Curmudgeon
Do you remember Eternal September, when Usenet was crushed by pretenders? The gates were swung open, the n00bs rushed unbroken, and harmony was torn asunder.

That doesn't mean they should be able to make arbitrary decisions that prevent customers from accessing new services offered by Google or some other innovative cloud services provider, but it does mean that they may need to define and implement packet prioritization policies that sometimes adversely impact other companies. Here's a simple analogy: if a transportation company built a facility adjacent to your neighborhood that resulted in continuous congestion that impeded your car's access in and out of your neighborhood, would you stand up on the side of road neutrality?

This debate really gets interesting when we add mobility to the equation. Anyone who has tried to use an iPhone in Manhattan during peak usage periods understands the powerful reality that bandwidth on mobile networks is a scarce resource. I don't have much sympathy for AT&T, which has clearly oversubscribed its network. They understood the network load characteristics of the iPhone, which consumes bandwidth in inefficient ways. The company is licensing new spectrum and building out more cells, but it can't possibly keep up with increased demand.

Consumers tolerate this because they have no choice. We continue to pay AT&T $30/month for unlimited data service that often stinks like a dead fish. (Sorry for the graphic analogy, but I was thinking about a circa-2001 Network Computing cover story we did on carrier service level agreements, where the cover art showed an SLA being used to wrap up dead fish, like an old newspaper. That summed up the value of carrier SLA's in those days.)  

Page:   1   2  Next  »

Add Your Comment:

Don't Stop At VoIP
June 2010

Network Computing June 2010


Salary

Video