Jasmine McTigue

Network Computing Blogger

Upcoming Events

Where the Cloud Touches Down: Simplifying Data Center Infrastructure Management

Thursday, July 25, 2013
10:00 AM PT/1:00 PM ET

In most data centers, DCIM rests on a shaky foundation of manual record keeping and scattered documentation. OpManager replaces data center documentation with a single repository for data, QRCodes for asset tracking, accurate 3D mapping of asset locations, and a configuration management database (CMDB). In this webcast, sponsored by ManageEngine, you will see how a real-world datacenter mapping stored in racktables gets imported into OpManager, which then provides a 3D visualization of where assets actually are. You'll also see how the QR Code generator helps you make the link between real assets and the monitoring world, and how the layered CMDB provides a single point of view for all your configuration data.

Register Now!

A Network Computing Webinar:
SDN First Steps

Thursday, August 8, 2013
11:00 AM PT / 2:00 PM ET

This webinar will help attendees understand the overall concept of SDN and its benefits, describe the different conceptual approaches to SDN, and examine the various technologies, both proprietary and open source, that are emerging. It will also help users decide whether SDN makes sense in their environment, and outline the first steps IT can take for testing SDN technologies.

Register Now!

More Events »

Subscribe to Newsletter

  • Keep up with all of the latest news and analysis on the fast-moving IT industry with Network Computing newsletters.
Sign Up

See more from this blogger

DIY Storage Part 2: Picking the Right SAN Software

This is the second installment in a series on building your own SAN. In part 1 I discussed why I decided to build my own array as a pilot project, and laid out the hardware specs.

In this post, I'll talk about how I choose the storage software to run on the machine. I looked at a variety of options, including open source and commercial products. Ultimately I chose Windows Storage Server 2012. Here's why.

More Insights


More >>

White Papers

More >>


More >>

I started with open source software including Openfiler and FreeNAS, but I had concerns with each. I had heard several user reports of unreliable performance with Openfiler's native iSCSI target driver. This was substantiated to me by the fact that Openfiler offers a $1,000 enhanced iSCSI module as a paid option. Plus, I found Openfiler's configuration menus to be cryptic, and setup was intensive--as many who have dabbled in open source applications can probably relate. That said, I believe Openfiler's commercial offerings are robust enough for enterprise use.

As for FreeNAS, it has limited capabilities. I wasn't looking so much for NFS as I was for teamed, gigabit, iSCSI multi-path I/O for storage uplink. Even though the SAN I'm building is a pilot project for non-mission-critical backup, I still wanted enterprise features.

On the paid side, Nexenta was my first stop, and I was excited to look it over. Why? Because Nexenta uses ZFS as its background file system. Solaris aficionados will tell you that ZFS is powerful stuff. Not only does it support a huge variety of RAID types across controllers and disparate drives, but it also supports native de-duplication and compression.

I evaluated Nexenta in a virtual machine to see how it shook out. Configuration is pleasantly simple. It supports VMware and Hyper-V, block-level mirroring of data, unlimited storage, and SSD caching. In addition, it supports FC and iSCSI MPIO, and as far as price goes for paid solutions, it's pretty reasonable.

But there are a ton of other options. The Cadillac of BYO SAN software is Datacore's SanMelody, which has recently been revamped and more economically licensed as SanSymphony. SanSymphony runs on top of a Windows server, and offers everything you expect from a Tier-1 SAN. In addition, it supports active/active controllers with cluster services on dual-node, shared backplane boxes, so you can build a dual-controller, fully redundant SAN. The downside is that you pay for Windows licensing on top of SanSymphony itself, which can be pricey, especially if you want all the bells and whistles.

Starwind makes a surprisingly inexpensive and mature iSCSI DIY SAN software package that also runs on Windows servers. You get snapshots, thin provisioning, active/active clustering, MPIO, and data dedupe for free! You only pay for replication services and large disk caches. This gives you the option of installing the software and getting a really good feel for it before buying, and it was my runner up for the OS on my SAN.

Finally, HP makes a product called StoreVirtual VSA. It runs on virtualized servers, making local disk space available to form multi-element striped member storage. So if you've got vSphere on a ton of boxes running on twin 400Gbyte SAS in RAID 1, why not take that 370+Gig of RAID 1 data and turn it into enormous, multi-box network volumes with HP's software? It's a bit of a specialty but it works, and if you're an HP shop or large enough, it may be a nice value proposition to create a whole other tier of storage out of wasted space.

In the end, however, Windows Storage Server 2012 won out. One reason is that because I'm using this little array in an evaluation sense, I was entitled to use my Technet Pro subscription to license SS2012 for evaluation purposes.

SS2012 installed easily, detected all the storage in my machine, and created redundant RAID sets across dissimilar-sized drives running on multiple controllers. Provisioning these disk pools into discrete volumes was easy, and it was even easier to set up as iSCSI or NFS targets for VMware ISO sharing, or auxiliary disk space. Multi-path iSCSI I/O works great, and I'm impressed with the management tools that Microsoft provides with this latest version.

SS2012 has snapshots, de-duplication, dynamic volume expansion and thin provisioning, which is the basic feature set I required. As you might imagine, it's slightly friendlier to Hyper-V than VMware (snapshot features are more sophisticated on VHD files), but it's a pleasure to install and use. I was up and running in about an hour and had a few VMware hosts connected to a couple iSCSI volumes.

What really won me over is that SS2012 is an enterprise-level product. It supports replication with Remote Differential Compression and built-in Microsoft tools. It can be configured on two-node systems with cluster services to provide active/active, fully redundant SAN configurations.

Licensing costs aren't out for this product yet, so if you don't have Technet, you are out of luck. But I am hoping that licenses are reasonable, because this software dovetails nicely into a Windows 2012 server infrastructures and delivers excellent performance even on minimal hardware.

Jasmine McTigue is the IT manager for Carwild Corp. She is responsible for IT infrastructure and has worked on numerous customer projects as well as ongoing network management and support throughout her 10-plus-year career.

Related Reading

Network Computing encourages readers to engage in spirited, healthy debate, including taking us to task. However, Network Computing moderates all comments posted to our site, and reserves the right to modify or remove any content that it determines to be derogatory, offensive, inflammatory, vulgar, irrelevant/off-topic, racist or obvious marketing/SPAM. Network Computing further reserves the right to disable the profile of any commenter participating in said activities.

Disqus Tips To upload an avatar photo, first complete your Disqus profile. | Please read our commenting policy.
Vendor Comparisons
Network Computing’s Vendor Comparisons provide extensive details on products and services, including downloadable feature matrices. Our categories include:

Research and Reports

Network Computing: April 2013

TechWeb Careers