Special Coverage Series

Network Computing

Special Coverage Series

Commentary

Tom Hollingsworth
Tom Hollingsworth

SDN, Overlays and Interior Decorating

Redesigning your network with SDN is kind of like interior decorating. Overlays let you paper over your existing network, while OpenFlow might require some rebuilding.

Overlays are quickly becoming a hot topic in the SDN space. One of the best-known proponents is Martin Casado and his merry band of hackers at Nicira/VMware. They're working on VMware NSX, a virtual networking overlay system.

The whole idea rests on the belief that tunneling your traffic across a virtual network built on top of the existing physical network is the best way to accomplish all things that SDN is looking to do. You don't have to worry about swapping out your switch OS for OpenFlow. You don't have to worry about spinning up an OpenDaylight controller. You just install NSX, let it do all the dirty work, and your network works the right way.

More Insights

Webcasts

More >>

White Papers

More >>

Reports

More >>

If your data center is a house that you want to remodel, then an overlay is like applying new wallpaper over whatever's already on the wall. So long as the pattern or color you choose doesn't allow anything below to bleed through, you're in good shape.

In other words, the overlay works so long as there are no underlying issues with your existing physical network. You have to assume that all patch cables are correctly connected and that loops and multipathing have been taken care of, either by a Layer 2 fabric such as TRILL or through judicious use of spanning tree.

Of course, issues with the physical network will affect the overlay. No amount of intelligence or processing power can compensate for someone unplugging the core switch or looping a connection without spanning tree present. Overlays are quick and easy--provided that the underlying structure is intact and functioning.

Rebuilding the Wall

Forwarding technologies such as OpenFlow seek to accomplish the same function as an overlay by totally different means. These technologies aim to remove impediments in the switch by throwing out unnecessary software or forwarding. They rely on a central controller to do much of the heavy lifting. This approach requires a bit more architectural work. It also requires planning, as well as an understanding that there may be outages during the switchover.

[What is SDN all about? Greg Ferro breaks it down in "SDN Is Business, OpenFlow Is Technology." ]

To go back to our interior design analogy, OpenFlow is like scraping the wallpaper and paint off to redecorate from the very base of the wall. In extreme cases, you may need to remove the drywall down to the studs and build out again.

It's going to be messy, and you may have to stare at a skeleton wall for a while until the work is done. But the proponents of this method will tell you that it pays off in the long run because you don't have to keep putting paper over paper until the whole mess slides off onto the floor. In other words, you don't have to worry about the underlying physical network becoming a disastrous mess because no one ever works on it because they're only fussing around with the overlay.

Which Way To Go?

Unfortunately, I don't have a solution here. Overlays versus OpenFlow/forwarding configuration is the new OSPF versus EIGRP debate, or "Tastes great!" versus "Less filling!" Each camp has its vision and supporting case studies to prove their way works best.

Based on some entertaining and heated discussions that I've seen on Twitter, I doubt the two sides will ever come to terms. I find it interesting that Casado used to be firmly seated in the OpenFlow camp, and has now transitioned fully into the overlay side of the house. Maybe he sees something that we don't.

One thing for certain is the significant uptick in attention to and excitement around networking. Incumbent vendors are touting new products and architectures, startups are fighting to for a toehold using SDN as a wedge, and there's even open-source efforts being applied to both network software and hardware. If you're planning on a network renovation, you won't suffer from a lack of options.



Related Reading



Network Computing encourages readers to engage in spirited, healthy debate, including taking us to task. However, Network Computing moderates all comments posted to our site, and reserves the right to modify or remove any content that it determines to be derogatory, offensive, inflammatory, vulgar, irrelevant/off-topic, racist or obvious marketing/SPAM. Network Computing further reserves the right to disable the profile of any commenter participating in said activities.

 
Disqus Tips To upload an avatar photo, first complete your Disqus profile. | Please read our commenting policy.
 

Editor's Choice

Research: 2014 State of Server Technology

Research: 2014 State of Server Technology

Buying power and influence are rapidly shifting to service providers. Where does that leave enterprise IT? Not at the cutting edge, thatís for sure: Only 19% are increasing both the number and capability of servers, budgets are level or down for 60% and just 12% are using new micro technology.
Get full survey results now! »

Vendor Turf Wars

Vendor Turf Wars

The enterprise tech market used to be an orderly place, where vendors had clearly defined markets. No more. Driven both by increasing complexity and Wall Street demands for growth, big vendors are duking it out for primacy -- and refusing to work together for IT's benefit. Must we now pick a side, or is neutrality an option?
Get the Digital Issue »

WEBCAST: Software Defined Networking (SDN) First Steps

WEBCAST: Software Defined Networking (SDN) First Steps


Software defined networking encompasses several emerging technologies that bring programmable interfaces to data center networks and promise to make networks more observable and automated, as well as better suited to the specific needs of large virtualized data centers. Attend this webcast to learn the overall concept of SDN and its benefits, describe the different conceptual approaches to SDN, and examine the various technologies, both proprietary and open source, that are emerging.
Register Today »

Related Content

From Our Sponsor

How Data Center Infrastructure Management Software Improves Planning and Cuts Operational Cost

How Data Center Infrastructure Management Software Improves Planning and Cuts Operational Cost

Business executives are challenging their IT staffs to convert data centers from cost centers into producers of business value. Data centers can make a significant impact to the bottom line by enabling the business to respond more quickly to market demands. This paper demonstrates, through a series of examples, how data center infrastructure management software tools can simplify operational processes, cut costs, and speed up information delivery.

Impact of Hot and Cold Aisle Containment on Data Center Temperature and Efficiency

Impact of Hot and Cold Aisle Containment on Data Center Temperature and Efficiency

Both hot-air and cold-air containment can improve the predictability and efficiency of traditional data center cooling systems. While both approaches minimize the mixing of hot and cold air, there are practical differences in implementation and operation that have significant consequences on work environment conditions, PUE, and economizer mode hours. The choice of hot-aisle containment over cold-aisle containment can save 43% in annual cooling system energy cost, corresponding to a 15% reduction in annualized PUE. This paper examines both methodologies and highlights the reasons why hot-aisle containment emerges as the preferred best practice for new data centers.

Monitoring Physical Threats in the Data Center

Monitoring Physical Threats in the Data Center

Traditional methodologies for monitoring the data center environment are no longer sufficient. With technologies such as blade servers driving up cooling demands and regulations such as Sarbanes-Oxley driving up data security requirements, the physical environment in the data center must be watched more closely. While well understood protocols exist for monitoring physical devices such as UPS systems, computer room air conditioners, and fire suppression systems, there is a class of distributed monitoring points that is often ignored. This paper describes this class of threats, suggests approaches to deploying monitoring devices, and provides best practices in leveraging the collected data to reduce downtime.

Cooling Strategies for Ultra-High Density Racks and Blade Servers

Cooling Strategies for Ultra-High Density Racks and Blade Servers

Rack power of 10 kW per rack or more can result from the deployment of high density information technology equipment such as blade servers. This creates difficult cooling challenges in a data center environment where the industry average rack power consumption is under 2 kW. Five strategies for deploying ultra-high power racks are described, covering practical solutions for both new and existing data centers.

Power and Cooling Capacity Management for Data Centers

Power and Cooling Capacity Management for Data Centers

High density IT equipment stresses the power density capability of modern data centers. Installation and unmanaged proliferation of this equipment can lead to unexpected problems with power and cooling infrastructure including overheating, overloads, and loss of redundancy. The ability to measure and predict power and cooling capability at the rack enclosure level is required to ensure predictable performance and optimize use of the physical infrastructure resource. This paper describes the principles for achieving power and cooling capacity management.