Networking

09:06 AM
Curt Beckmann
Curt Beckmann
Commentary
Connect Directly
Twitter
RSS
E-Mail
50%
50%

SDN: Open Source Advances Interoperability

Open source software is helping to drive interoperability and innovation in software-defined networking.

I've been working actively in the area of software-defined networking for the past three years, with a particular focus on the challenges of delivering products that are both interesting and interoperable. I'm happy to report that recent events in the SDN space are bringing the once-cloudy future into much sharper focus.

Among other efforts, the Forwarding Abstractions working group I chair in the Open Network Foundation (ONF) will soon finalize a spec that will improve OpenFlow scalability and interoperability. The industry investments in network functions virtualization (NFV) and the progress at OpenDaylight are also very helpful.

If you've been tracking SDN, you know it refers to an architecture where the control plane can be decoupled from the data plane. But what does that translate to in practical terms? For example, should SDN-related topics already be part of your equipment purchase criteria? I expect you can guess the answer: "It depends."

Key dependencies include: How central is IT to your strategic differentiation? Do you have significant software development resources, or can you instead fund it externally? Does your industry suggest that you should be near the bleeding edge of IT?

[New tech breakthroughs will change our lives. Learn Why You Should Be Excited About Future Tech.]

In the buzz around SDN, we've seen suggestions that convergence toward a new and common networking stack will soon occur. We're told it will resemble the familiar compute stack that lets buyers make independent, best-of-breed choices for software and hardware. That's a compelling vision, but it's also a long-term one.

To realize that vision, we need rich and open interoperability. I must mention "standards," but we all know that there are standards that fail to enable true interoperability. In purely software environments, open source can often simultaneously enable interoperability and API innovation better than standards, which typically move more slowly than open source software. On the other hand, insisting on end-to-end open source can potentially stifle innovation by discouraging investment.

I'll talk about interoperability and openness on April 2 in an Interop Las Vegas session: "How SDN Ready is Your Network Infrastructure?" The core promise of SDN depends on efforts toward openness, so I'll discuss OpenFlow, Open vSwitch, OpenStack, and OpenDaylight. If time permits, I may even comment on OpenCompute and OpenContrail, and perhaps some other OpenWhatsit™ (JK!) that pops up by then.

A good discussion of interoperability must include conformance testing, too. The ONF's Forwarding Abstractions working group's spec, which will be nearing release by the time of Interop, creates a framework that allows industry participants to precisely define and share specific SDN functionality "profiles" well ahead of SDN runtime.

The profiles, called table type patterns (TTPs), can be defined by switch vendors, application vendors, customers, or other interest groups such as standards bodies (including ONF working groups) or industry consortia. TTPs dramatically reduce the scalability and interoperability challenges that are otherwise present with arrival of OpenFlow 1.3-enabled products. My talk will provide more details on how TTPs actually deliver those benefits. You can get a mini-preview of TTPs from these slides at SlideShare.

My session wouldn't be complete without some mention of some controversial subjects like SDN washing and commoditization too, but perhaps it's better if I leave the provocative topics for you folks in the audience. I'm looking forward to sharing my views at Interop Las Vegas, March 31 - April 4. Save the date, and I will see you there.

Join top-rated speaker Ivan Pepelnjak for a half-day workshop Designing The Virtual Network For The Software-Defined Data Center. Ivan will cover the pros and cons of core SDN components, explore overlay virtual networks and tunnel protocols, and help you select optimal networking technology for a private or public cloud deployment. Register now for Interop Las Vegas. Use the code SMBLOG to get $200 off the current price of Total Access and Conference Passes.

Curt Beckmann is a Principal Architect and Brocade's lead representative at the ONF, where he is chair of the Forwarding Abstractions Working Group and a member of the Chipmakers' Advisory Board. He entered networking as an ASIC architect at Bay Networks (later Nortel ... View Full Bio
Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Comments
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
Drew Conry-Murray
50%
50%
Drew Conry-Murray,
User Rank: Strategist
3/4/2014 | 4:45:26 PM
Open in the air
I'm at the Open Networking Summit and the word "open" is being thrown around about as much as "SDN." OpenDaylight, OpenFlow, OpenStack and other efforts are on the lips of every presenter. From a cynical viewpoint, all this talk may just be "open-washing." But I think there's more to it than at. There are so many moving parts to be addressed when you link applications to virtual compute, network and storage that no one vendor can deliver it all, and no one vendor can control it. The open-source efforts that tackle pieces of it (northbound APIs, switch configuration, network orchestration, controllers, etc) create a framework of usuable components. Of course vendors will try to leverage the framework to their own advantage, but I think these open efforts will make SDN and network virtualization more viable more quickly.
Hot Topics
7
Understanding IPv6: Link-Local 'Magic'
Denise Fishburne, Cisco Champion,  7/24/2014
6
Guide: The Open Compute Project and Your Data Center
James M. Connolly, Editor in Chief, The Enterprise Cloud Site,  7/21/2014
4
Network Security: An Oxymoron In The Cloud Era?
Rajat Bhargava, Co-Founder & CEO, JumpCloud,  7/22/2014
White Papers
Register for Network Computing Newsletters
Cartoon
Current Issue
2014 Private Cloud Survey
2014 Private Cloud Survey
Respondents are on a roll: 53% brought their private clouds from concept to production in less than one year, and 60% ­extend their clouds across multiple datacenters. But expertise is scarce, with 51% saying acquiring skilled employees is a roadblock.
Video
Slideshows
Twitter Feed