SSD Failure Rates

Posted by George Crump
July 26, 2010

Ever since SSD drives began their slow march to mainstream storage, there has been a constant chorus over concerns about SSD failure rates and questions on if the technology was ready for the enterprise. Most of the concern lies around how many writes a SSD drive can sustain. Vendors of enterprise SSD drives have gone to great lengths to make sure that today's SSD drives used in the data center will not have premature write issues. With the improvements in the quality of the NAND and the capabilities of the Flash controller, if the right vendor is selected, Flash SSDs should outlive most mechanical drives.

Although some are deserved, many of the concerns about SSD failure rates seems to come from personal experiences with consumer grade compact Flash, like those found in cameras or inexpensive thumb drives, which have had a sketchy past. Interestingly, if your personal experience was a mid-1990 RAM based SSD you would have the opposite reaction. RAM based SSDs have always proven to be extremely reliable. Flash is different. Its persistent storage state means that memory cells need to be written to. If the memory cell is full,, it needs to be erased and written over. The primary concern around Flash-based SSD is write endurance. In other words, how many write cycles can they handle? This typically is addressed in two ways. First by the type of SSD used and second by the intelligence on the controller. There are two types of Flash based technology: single level cell (SLC) and multi-level cell (MLC). Most MLC drives hold four states per cell, where SLC holds one state per cell. As a result MLC is higher capacity but more prone to failure, SLC is more expensive but also more reliable and have a much higher write endurance. Most enterprise drives are SLC based for this reason.

All Flash drives have a controller. The controller handles how data is written to the flash drive and it is one of the bigger differentiators of SSD quality. One of the controller's primary functions is to make sure that data is written evenly to each cell on the drive. This keeps a group of cells from wearing out before the other cells on the flash drive. The controller also manages excess cells on the drive, making those available as other cells wear out. The controller may even group the writes so that it can write larger blocks of data to the drive, which further helps with both performance and write longevity. The Flash controller technology has become so advanced that we are seeing a few vendors offer MLC based SSD drives to the enterprise. They can do this by leveraging all of the above controller technologies. While I'm not sure that MLC will replace SLC in the enterprise, we may see a tiering of SSD, just like we have today in hard drives.

While there are other factors in delivering reliable SSD technology the controller intelligence that the SSD supplier uses may be the key differentiator in reducing SSD failure rates. As we discuss in our article "Pay Attention to Flash Controllers when Comparing SSD Systems," it is reasonable to expect seven to ten years of life out of today's SSDs with the capabilities of today's controller technology, which is really beyond the life of any enterprise primary storage device.

Related Reading

More backup-recovery Insights