Upcoming Events

Cloud Connect
Santa Clara
Feb 13-16, 2012

Cloud Connect brings together the entire cloud eco-system to better understand the transformation we're experiencing and promises to be the defining event of the cloud computing industry. Learn about the latest cloud technologies and platforms from thought leaders in Cloud Connect’s comprehensive conference.

Register Now!

More Events »

Subscribe to Newsletter

  • Keep up with all of the latest news and analysis on the fast-moving IT industry with Network Computing newsletters.
Sign Up
Network & Systems Infrastructure
S N E A K   P R E V I E W  
Matrix E1 Optical Access Switch Boosts Bandwidth

  February 18, 2002
  By Peter Morrissey


It's happened again, folks. The stakes in the network-bandwidth game have been raised by another order of magnitude. It seems as though just yesterday Ethernet made the jump from 100 Mb to 1 Gb, but the technology just keeps putting out. I had the opportunity to get my hands on a 10 Gigabit­capable solution, the Enterasys Networks Matrix E1 Optical Access Switch. After putting the beta E1 through its paces in Network Computing's Real-World Labs® at Syracuse University I can say without a doubt that 10 Gigabit has arrived.



If you're feeling guilty that you aren't even close to taxing your 1-Gbps or even 100-Mbps links yet, don't worry -- you're not alone. The average network doesn't need anything close to 10 gigabits. However, if you are feeding a bunch of gigabit links into a backbone and are seeing it stressed out, the Matrix E1 Optical Switch can deal with it. Keep in mind that you don't have to need 10 gigabits of bandwidth to take advantage of a 10-Gbps interface; once you exceed the capacity of 1 Gigabit, the next jump is 10 Gigabit.

The technology is also a great way to replace multiple gigabit trunks between switches. Trunking makes it possible to connect multiple 1-Gbps ports together as one virtual connection, because the traffic is equally balanced among the connections. The disadvantage of this approach is that it requires fiber for each connection, and it can be difficult to troubleshoot. Aside from using less fiber, one 10-Gbps connection provides a cleaner solution.



If you're looking to purchase a 10-Gbps switch today, be prepared to make a commitment to Enterasys. You may have noticed that the IEEE 802.3ae standard that governs 10 Gigabit Ethernet has not yet been finalized, and it probably won't be completed until the middle of this year. The 10-Gbps uplink on the Enterasys switch uses a nonstandard combination of 850-nm light wave with a CWDM (Course Wave Division Multiplexing) physical interface. This physical interface, which will not be part of 802.3ae, requires 62.5-micron, multimode fiber terminated with an SC connector. Given that the necessary fiber is multimode, the distance between switches will be limited to 300 meters.

During the year, Enterasys will be rolling out all four versions of the physical interfaces that will be supported by 802.3ae, which will include longer-range options running over single-mode fiber. For now, however, you will need Matrix E1 Optical Access Switches on both ends of your 10-Gbps link. Standards are important, but if you require more bandwidth now, the E1 will provide it until the standards details are worked out.

Vendor Information

Matrix E1 Optical Access Switch, $26,970 as tested (list); pricing based on configuration. Available: Now. Enterasys Networks, (603) 332-9400; fax (603) 337-2211.
www.enterasys.com/switching/

The E1 was designed as a Layer 2 switch, with no pretense of being anything else. The final code will include support for capabilities you would hope to find in a Layer 2 switch, such as 802.1q and 802.1p trunking, multicast support, VLAN (virtual LAN) support and port monitoring. I was disappointed that Enterasys wouldn't let me examine these features in the beta version of E1 I tested, even with the greater flexibility Network Computing gives beta products for Sneak Previews (as compared with feature reviews). By the time you read this, however, Enterasys will be delivering its production product, so you'll be able to test the features for yourself. The company also will be adding 10 Gigabit interfaces to its Layer 3 switches.

Maximum Bandwidth

The E1 I received from Enterasys came with 12 fiber gigabit ports and a modular 10-Gbps uplink. The gigabit ports all had MT-RJ interfaces, which are each about the size of an RJ-45 connector. Four of the 12 interfaces were GBICs (Gigabit Interface Converters) -- hot-swappable adapters that let you easily change from single-mode to multimode fiber interfaces. The GBICs also support MT-RJ connections, making it possible to fit all 12 interfaces in a small form factor, which comes in at 1.5 Us or 2.6 inches high.

I was able to use the E1's telnet, Web and serial-port management capabilities to do basic tasks, such as configuring an IP address for the switch. One thing I can say for sure is that the E1 can move frames -- after all, that's its main purpose. I hammered the product with a barrage of tests using a pair of Spirent Communications SmartBits 6000B testers (see "How I Tested 10 Gigabit," below). No matter what I tried, however, I was unable to get the E1 to drop a frame. The switch exhibited 20 gigabits of unadulterated wire-speed performance.

I used a variety of frame sizes for testing. The minimum-size frames, 64 bytes, are the most difficult to forward without frame loss -- the smaller the frame, the more frames that are transmitted per second. When running frames through a switch, the Ethernet header of every frame needs to be inspected, and the bridge table has to be examined to determine the port from which to send the frame.

It's possible for a 10-Gbps connection to handle nearly 15 million 64-byte frames per second in each direction, for a total of almost 30 million frames per second. Therefore, the E1 had no problem handling the nearly 30 million frames per second it had to process when I blasted it with 64-byte frames.

Whether or not you are ready to make the jump to 10 Gigabit Ethernet on your network, the Matrix E1 Optical Access Switch is ready to produce exactly what Enterasys designed it for: raw bandwidth.

Peter Morrissey is a full-time faculty member of Syracuse University's School of Information Studies, and a contributing editor and columnist for Network Computing. Send your comments on this column to him at ppmorris@syr.edu.


How I Tested 10 Gigabit



Testing (chart)


Click here to enlarge

To generate 10 Gbps in each direction of the full-duplex connection, I used a Spirent Communications SmartBits tester behind each switch. Each SmartBits device had 10 full-duplex 1-Gbps connections to its switch for a total of 10 gigabits in each direction.

  • Full-Mesh Throughput Test. For this test, I transmitted different size frames at 100 percent utilization. With each port transmitting at 10 Gbps, the total utilization in each direction was 10 gigabits. I used a full-mesh test setup so that every 1-Gbps port divided its traffic evenly among all the corresponding ports on the other end. This made the switch work a little harder than sending to just one port. The result was that even with smaller frame sizes, which caused the switch to process more frames per second, the switch didn't drop a single frame. This is known as true wire-speed throughput.

  • Latency Test. For this test, each gigabit SmartBits port generated frames and measured the time it took for them to arrive at the opposite SmartBits port. Multiple frames were measured, and I took the worst case, or the frame that exhibited the highest latency, for each test. Even the worst case showed such low levels of latency that it would not be significant, even for sensitive applications like VoIP (voice over IP).


Research and Reports

Hypervisor Derby
August 2011

Network Computing: August 2011

TechWeb Careers